SAINT PETER, Minn. - Jack Isroff scored an unlikely goal for Gustavus with 30 seconds left in regulation, but sudden death overtime killed the Gusties, falling to No. 22 Saint John's, 2-1, in the MIAC Playoff Semifinal.
The Gusties (12-4-3, 8-0-2 MIAC) will now wait until Monday at 10 a.m. to see the NCAA Division III Men's Soccer Selection Show to find out if their NPI is good enough to enter the national tournament.
With just five minutes remaining in the first half, No. 22 Saint John's took the lead after a failed clearance, getting on the end of it with a volley and slotting it past junior goalkeeper
Jackson Baker (Excelsior, Minn.). The Johnnies held a slight advantage in shots on goal, 4-2 and Gustavus had a lead in corners, 4-1.
In the second half, Gustavus was on the front foot for the majority, but struggled to find the answer for most of the 45 minutes. With just under 10 minutes to play, the game was seemingly over, as Saint John's was released onto a breakaway with only Baker to beat. Baker came off his line and made the first save which fell right to another Johnnie at the edge of the penalty area. Senior
Simon Woods (Sioux Falls, S.D.) fully outstretched his right leg to save the second attempt by Saint John's, saving the game for Gustavus. Sophomore
Kieran Mahan (Wayzata, Minn.) had a half bicycle attempt later, but the shot went directly to the goalkeeper. The true heroics came with under a minute left. Senior
Leo Runestad (Northfield, Minn.) played a long throw-in into the penalty area and after it bounced around, it fell to junior
Cal Avery (Middleton, Wis.). Avery took a shot first-time and it deflected off of senior
Jack Isroff (Valparaiso, Ind.) and through multiple Johnnie legs to tie the game. Gustavus held the advantage in shots on goal in the second half, 7-3, and the pressure burst in the dying moments in addition to a 6-1 corner kick advantage.
Senior
Max Just (Lakeville, Minn.) had the best Gustie chance in overtime with a close in shot that just went over the crossbar. Overtime lasted all of 3:07 before the second corner kick of the game for Saint John's proved lethal for the Gusties. A ball was played onto the back post and a header fell right to a Johnnie, who was able to tap the ball into the net.
Gustavus led in shots on goal, 9-8, and in corner kicks, 10-2, but could not make the small margins count to find a winner in regulation or overtime. Now, the Gusties will wait and watch the rest of the nation this weekend, hoping their NPI, which was No. 34 heading into this afternoon, is enough for a bid to the 2026 NCAA Division III Men's Soccer Tournament.